Accessing local Civic Pride


DSCN2461

Barry Pearson wrote an excellent column in the Ashbourne News Telegraph a couple of weeks ago about pride. It is in scarce supply these days and he made a good point about recognising and celebrating it. Pride is incredibly powerful as an emotion when it is used effectively. It made me think… are we proud of Ashbourne and if not why not?

When I talk to people around the town I sense a really strong identity with Ashbourne and what it stands for. I’m still a newcomer with just ten years here so I can’t claim to carry it in my blood but I am a very proud Yorkshireman of 50 years. I think the Ashbourne identity boils down to basic family values over generations: hard work, personal responsibility, decency and honesty. Its greatest illustration is the turnout when the traditional events take place – Shrovetide and Remembrance.

Sadly many other things don’t elicit the same response. What I sense is that while Ashburnians are proud of being born in the town they don’t have the same pride in the way Ashbourne is today. There is a mismatch between the people organising things and the people who live here in the town itself. There are well-attended events but they are attended disproportionately by tourists and not by Ashbourne’s residents. The news that Aldi is possibly coming was greeted with almost universal relief – at last something that is going to benefit residents. Compare that heartfelt response with the reaction to Marks and Spencer’s, the new toilet block, or the library.

There is a real frustration that the real voice of Ashbourne is not being heard. I would guess that very few of our residents have spoken with Patrick McLoughlin, our MP. I suspect even fewer could name our MEP. The Town Council minutes are available online – they show that most meetings have no members of the public present and that only occasionally is someone present from the press or in support of a specific planning application. The District Council only has the reputation as the bringer of bad news. I personally have never been asked my views by either my Town or District Councillor and so we vote on political lines when it comes to local elections too. Our Town Councillors do an astounding job with unsociable hours and a tough legal and budgetary challenge. They must be frustrated at having to do it on their own by relying on their own personal experience and knowledge.

The impact of this is a massive lost opportunity. You can take virtually any of the hot Ashbourne topics of the moment and get some really interesting and insightful views. I have discussed traffic, markets and housing recently and learned more in five minutes from talking face-to-face or through social media with Ashburnians than I’ve read in the previous few weeks. There is no shortage of opinion but part of the Ashbourne identity seems to be a browbeaten feeling of inevitability. That it’s a done deal. That money and back-handers talk. That it won’t happen because….. That there is no point in speaking up because no-one listens anyway!

This is unfortunate not least because our democratic system works on the principle that silence is agreement. Our repressed opinions actually support the flawed policies and wrong decisions that seem right to our politicians and so the cycle continues. There are still grievances which run deep which have little to do with money: the ugly wall by the park, footpaths, the closure of Coffee Stop, potholes, control of shop colour schemes – and yet “they” are seemingly happy to spend lots of money on a new library and a toilet block. “They” are spending lots of money on things we never asked for and not doing the things we really want. I am sure there are rational explanations but fundamentally we as voters are not doing a good enough job of telling our decision makers what will make us happy. Currently they are having to guess.

Coming back to my original point. I sometimes think that I am prouder of Ashbourne than many of those people who have lived here from birth. I have no right to be and I may be proud of the “wrong” things. Civic Pride is about higher things than who has a badge, title, longevity or money. It is a beliefthat there is something worth telling the world about our town; considering ourselves some of the lucky few to live here. The general perception of people I talk to around the country is that I live in a beautiful town in a beautiful part of the country. With pride comes a confidence that your views are as good as anyone’s and woe betide the person who puts money or personal gain ahead of our legacy.

I think that at the moment, for most people, the process is broken and something radical is needed to fix it. Some time ago it was mooted that Ashbourne could be branded as Britain’s Most Beautiful Town. We have a lot of natural assets which could form the foundations of that claim. If we could get our Councillors, our voluntary organisations, District support, and most importantly our residents behind that objective we may be able to restore our Civic Pride and recreate a great place to live and not just to visit.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Barry Pearson wrote an excellent column in the Ashbourne News Telegraph a couple of weeks ago about pride. It is in scarce supply these days and he made a good point about recognising and celebrating it. Pride is incredibly powerful as an emotion when it is used effectively. It made me think… are we proud of Ashbourne and if not why not?

 

When I talk to people around the town I sense a really strong identity with Ashbourne and what it stands for. I’m still a newcomer with just ten years here so I can’t claim to carry it in my blood but I am a very proud Yorkshireman of 50 years. I think the Ashbourne identity boils down to basic family values over generations: hard work, personal responsibility, decency and honesty. Its greatest illustration is the turnout when the traditional events take place – Shrovetide and Remembrance.

 

Sadly many other things don’t elicit the same response. What I sense is that while Ashburnians are proud of being born in the town they don’t have the same pride in the way Ashbourne is today. There is a mismatch between the people organising things and the people who live here in the town itself. There are well-attended events but they are attended disproportionately by tourists and not by Ashbourne’s residents. The news that Aldi is possibly coming was greeted with almost universal relief – at last something that is going to benefit residents. Compare that heartfelt response with the reaction to Marks and Spencer’s, the new toilet block, or the library.

 

There is a real frustration that the real voice of Ashbourne is not being heard. I would guess that very few of our residents have spoken with Patrick McLoughlin, our MP. I suspect even fewer could name our MEP. The Town Council minutes are available online – they show that most meetings have no members of the public present and that only occasionally is someone present from the press or in support of a specific planning application. The District Council only has the reputation as the bringer of bad news. I personally have never been asked my views by either my Town or District Councillor and so we vote on political lines when it comes to local elections too. Our Town Councillors do an astounding job with unsociable hours and a tough legal and budgetary challenge. They must be frustrated at having to do it on their own by relying on their own personal experience and knowledge.

 

The impact of this is a massive lost opportunity. You can take virtually any of the hot Ashbourne topics of the moment and get some really interesting and insightful views. I have discussed traffic, markets and housing recently and learned more in five minutes from talking face-to-face or through social media with Ashburnians than I’ve read in the previous few weeks. There is no shortage of opinion but part of the Ashbourne identity seems to be a browbeaten feeling of inevitability. That it’s a done deal. That money and back-handers talk. That it won’t happen because….. That there is no point in speaking up because no-one listens anyway!

 

This is unfortunate not least because our democratic system works on the principle that silence is agreement. Our repressed opinions actually support the flawed policies and wrong decisions that seem right to our politicians and so the cycle continues. There are still grievances which run deep which have little to do with money: the ugly wall by the park, footpaths, the closure of Coffee Stop, potholes, control of shop colour schemes – and yet “they” are seemingly happy to spend lots of money on a new library and a toilet block. “They” are spending lots of money on things we never asked for and not doing the things we really want. I am sure  there are rational explanations but fundamentally we as voters are not doing a good enough job of telling our decision makers what will make us happy. Currently they are having to guess.

 

Coming back to my original point. I sometimes think that I am prouder of Ashbourne than many of those people who have lived here from birth. I have no right to be and I may be proud of the “wrong” things. Civic Pride is about higher things than who has a badge, title, longevity or money. It is a belief that there is something worth telling the world about our town; considering ourselves some of the lucky few to live here. The general perception of people I talk to around the country is that I live in a beautiful town in a beautiful part of the country. With pride comes a confidence that your views are as good as anyone’s and woe betide the person who puts money or personal gain ahead of our legacy.

 

I think that at the moment, for most people, the process is broken and something radical is needed to fix it. Some time ago it was mooted that Ashbourne could be branded as Britain’s Most Beautiful Town. We have a lot of natural assets which could form the foundations of that claim. If we could get our Councillors, our voluntary organisations, District support, and most importantly our residents behind that objective we may be able to restore our Civic Pride and recreate a great place to live and not just to visit.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

About justaukcook

/kʊk/ Not a chef, not an epicure, not a foodie. Just one who likes to prepare food – What really happens in the kitchen and on the high street is what I write about. Follow me on Twitter @Justaukcook and on https://www.facebook.com/justaukcook
This entry was posted in Opinion and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s